|
|
This week: Full Court Controversy
Civil is written by three people who are tired of news in its current form. Nathan tends to lean right, while Liam tends to lean left. Max is your editor.
Together, we're giving you perspectives from both sides in a single place. Bridge the perception gap. Understand more. Argue less. |
How Civil is Structured |
- What: We'll highlight the facts you need to know about our story.
- How: We'll show you the narratives from the Left and Right and specific articles that support them.
- Transparency: We'll highlight coverage of our story that's (relatively) objective. There's hope!
- Civility Scavenger Hunt: We want to hear from you! The best submission will receive a $25 Amazon gift card and be featured in next week's newsletter.
|
|
|
|
|
|
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW |
Court Is In Session |
|
Katherine Chuang |
On Friday night, Ruth Bader Ginsburg --the second woman to ever sit on the Supreme Court-- died at the age of 87 after a long battle with cancer. She was an icon for politicians on both sides of the aisle and founded of the ACLU’s Women’s Rights Project. (History)
Her passing has added another element to the Presidential campaign: Should Trump and the Republican-controlled Senate nominate and confirm her replacement before the Presidential election? (AP)
Here’s what you need to know |
Facts, Not Funny Business |
|
|
|
|
|
|
HOW IT'S BEING SPUN |
Narrative Overview |
|
|
|
Shutterstock |
|
|
Now that you know what's up, let's go deeper. Here are the narratives our team has identified and the headlines that support them. These headlines are not necessarily false, but they do support the biased narrative from each side. |
|
|
|
|
Bottom Line |
|
The open Supreme Court seat left by the passing of the “Notorious RBG” seems to have pushed other issues like COVID-19 and police brutality out of the limelight, for now. If the public eye is diverted away from issues that Trump has generally polled poorly on, he could benefit. This could also help voters forget about Biden’s public speaking gaffes.
Either way, narratives from the Left and Right are doing their best to influence how voters view the Supreme Court nomination. Here’s what they’re saying:
However, every rosé has its thorn (sorry, already in Friday mode). If the empty seat is filled before the election, some single-issue pro-life voters may be less likely to vote in November if their priorities are met. Trump, who currently trails Biden by 6.9% in national polling averages, needs to maximize turnout if he wants to keep the keys to the White House. If confirmed before the election, Biden could benefit if Democratic voters are galvanized by the threats of a solid Conservative majority. However, liberal backlash could also strengthen right-wing resolve.
This confirmation could very well make or break some poor political strategists' career. We’re just glad the pressure isn’t on us. |
|
|
|
|
|
TRANSPARENCY |
It's Not All Bias |
While you've seen just how biased news outlets can be, they are fair sometimes. Here are articles that pleasantly surprised us by conceding a point that supports the other narrative. |
|
|
Susan Collins Says Republicans Should Wait on Supreme Court Replacement Until after Election |
|
|
|
America Can't Afford to Wait for a New Supreme Court Justice | Opinion |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Civility Scavenger Hunt |
|
If you've made it this far, congrats! Now, we want to hear from you.
Not only will we be featuring the best submission in next week's newsletter, but we'll also be giving that reader a $25 Amazon gift card! Here's what your submission could look like:
- A short story about a civil conversation you've had recently. What was it like? How did you avoid a shouting match?
- A resource that's widened your perspective and helped you be more civil. This could be a movie, book, app, etc.
- A prominent figure (like RBG) that you think personifies civility. What can we learn from them?
Shoot us an email with your response and we might feature you next week! |
|
|
Want to Learn More About Our Bias Ratings? |
|
|
Our bias ratings are generated by AllSides, which they establish using input from thousands of users and a bipartisan review board.
|
Until next Wednesday, that's all from us. By now, you're a little more Civil. Well done!
P.S. No survey from us this week. If you have feedback just reply to this email:) |
|
|
|
|
|